Editor's Comments

Dear Steve,

I have heard from my two readers of your paper and I sorry to say that neither felt able to recommend its publication in JCS.

Since neither submitted a detailed report, I cannot give you the reasons for their decision. This is annoying for you as an author and awkward for me as an editor. But if a busy scholar reads through a paper, judges it unsuitable for publication, and decides not to spend further time on it, we have to accept that. At least they both responded fairly quickly.

Yours sincerely,


Author's Appeal

Back & Forth

Final Rejection

Author's final comment